Who Guards The Guard?
New research from Concordia University in Montreal shows security software might actually make online computing less safe.
For the study, Mohammad Mannan, assistant professor in the Concordia Institute for Information Systems Engineering (CIISE), and PhD student Xavier de Carné de Carnavalet examined 14 commonly used software programs that claim to make computers safer by protecting data, blocking out viruses or shielding users from questionable content on the Internet.
Time and again, the researchers found that these programs were doing more harm than good.
“Out of the products we analysed, we found that all of them lower the level of security normally provided by current browsers, and often bring serious security vulnerabilities,” says de Carnavalet, who was surprised by how widespread the problem has become.
“While a couple of fishy ad-related products were known to behave badly in the same set-up, it’s stunning to observe that products intended to bring security and safety to users can fail as badly.”
At the root of the problem is how security applications act as gatekeepers, filtering dangerous or unwanted elements by inspecting secure web pages before they reach the browser.
Normally, browsers themselves have to check the certificate delivered by a website, and verify that it has been issued by a proper entity, called a Certification Authority (CA).
But security products make the computer “think” that they are themselves a fully entitled CA, thus allowing them to fool browsers into trusting any certificate issued by the products.
This research has important implications not only for everyday computer users, but also for the companies producing the software programs themselves.
“We reported our findings to the respective vendors so they can fix their products,” says Mannan. “Not all of them have responded yet, but we hope to bring their attention to these issues.”
“We also hope that our work will bring more awareness among users when choosing a security suite or software to protect their children’s online activities,” says de Carnavalet, who cautions that internet users should not view these security products as a panacea.
“We encourage consumers to keep their browser, operating system and other applications up-to-date, so that they benefit from the latest security patches,” he says.
“Parental control apps exist that do not interfere with secure content, but merely block websites by their domain name, which is probably effective enough.”
This research was supported in part by an NSERC Discovery Grant, a Vanier Canada Graduate Scholarship and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada’s Contributions Program. These findings were originally presented at the Network and Distributed System Security Symposium 2016.